Environmentalism, enemy of capitalism. How a Selfish Society is Destroying the planet

Re-Establishing Altruism As A Viable Social Norm

Environmentalism & Altruism

Sharing things and helping other people may damage the economy, but it's a great way to decrease our environmental footprint. Since the earth’s resources are finite, competing to outconsume one another is a self-destructive course of action. This, however, is the natural outcome of capitalism, with its focus on money at the expense of all else.

As technology has increased the impact of human activity on our environment, concerns about environmental matters such as pollution, climate change, resource depletion are being treated increasingly seriously. However, the USA and some other countries still pursue economic gain above all else. Such arrogant short-sightedness would be unthinkable from a less powerful nation, and does at least highlight the problems of highly concentrating power.

The simple dogma of ‘do whatever makes money’ has lead to increasingly pathological overconsumption. The ethos of competition has produced societies of busy, stressed people often lonely and depressed. As our economic system steadily grows in scope, ever more aspects of life are professionalises, decreasing opportunities for unpaid, heart felt action by crowding it out through an increased volume of commercially motivated transactions. By commodifying our relationships - with other people, the wider community and the natural envionment as a whole - ever more activity is brought into the zero-sum, competitive model. The wasteful practices associated with the profit motive are damaging our social and the natural environment. However, our current problems may look small in years to come, as new technologies such as genetic engineering and nanotechnology are magnifying the potential for human impact on the environment.

Costing the Earth... As a species, we have a decision to make about how (some would say whether) we want to develop genetic engineering. It well illustrates the dangers of taking a proprietary approach. One the one hand, a successful development would yield great dividends in the form of sales, royalties from intellectual property rights etc. On the other a failure could cause catastrophic damage to the environment. The cost to planet earth of disastrous environmental damage would go not only exceed the resources of any company or state to put right, it could go beyond any financial reckoning. Standard economics doesn’t have a lot to say about calculations of this nature. Although alternative models are being developed, a fundamental rethink is necessary if we are to overcome this risk, for the simple reason that for a limited liability company the calculation becomes a lot easier - any costs incurred over and above the value of its assets can be safely (sic.) ignored since if a disaster were to happen the company could be declared bankrupt and wouldn’t be liable.
Many countries have legislation to try to safeguard public health and the environment. However, even without the very significant problem of rent-seeking, such legislation cannot be expected to be very effective, with technologies developing so quickly, and potential revenues so large. The need for such ad hoc extra rules is in itself an admission of one of the more serious problems of capitalism; the ‘free market’ is unsuitable means to ensure people safeguard the environment - the one resource which mankind really cannot afford to lose.

Environmental safety seems unlikely to be assured under capitalism, which insulates people from their affect on their environment. Altruistic economics, by contrast, encourages people to consider the impact of their actions on others.

Downloads Title Author(s) Date Reference
Warning to Humanity Union of Concerned Scientists 1992 Nov
Industrial Ecology - An Environmental Agenda for Industry Hardin Tibbs 1993 Global Business Network.
Bugs R Us David Suzuki & Holly Dressel 1999-01-01 Canadian Broadcasting Corporation From Naked Ape to Superspecies 1
Big Foot David Suzuki & Holly Dressel 1999-01-01 Canadian Broadcasting Corporation From Naked Ape to Superspecies 2
Sez Who David Suzuki & Holly Dressel 1999-01-01 Canadian Broadcasting Corporation From Naked Ape to Superspecies 3
Follow the Money David Suzuki & Holly Dressel 1999-01-01 Canadian Broadcasting Corporation From Naked Ape to Superspecies 6
Globalization Rules David Suzuki & Holly Dressel 1999-01-01 Canadian Broadcasting Corporation From Naked Ape to Superspecies 7
Complex Pleasures David Suzuki & Holly Dressel 1999-01-01 Canadian Broadcasting Corporation From Naked Ape to Superspecies 8
Unnatural Selection David Suzuki & Holly Dressel 1999-01-01 Canadian Broadcasting Corporation From Naked Ape to Superspecies 4
Your Money Or Your Life Forms David Suzuki & Holly Dressel 1999-01-01 Canadian Broadcasting Corporation From Naked Ape to Superspecies 5
Interview about The Water Crisis Lester Brown
What is Sustainability? Thomas Walsh 2005-10-19 Sustainable Voices
The Oil We Eat - Following the food chain back to Iraq Richard Manning 2004 Harper's Magazine

FURTHER READING » Ecology Downloads